LEGAL DEFENSES AGAINST DEFAMATION CLAIMS IN CIVIL PROCEEDINGS
Introduction
Article 33 of the Constitution affirms that every person has the right to freedom of expression. However, in exercising this right, individuals must respect the rights and reputations of others. Defamation occurs when someone uses words against another to incite hatred, contempt, or ridicule, potentially injuring their reputation in their office, trade, or profession, or damaging their financial credit. The law protects individuals from harm to their reputation caused by false and derogatory remarks through the enactment of the Defamation Act, Chapter 36, Laws of Kenya (“the Act”).
When confronted with a defamation claim, the following defenses may be employed:
- Publication without malice
This defense, as provided under Section 12 of the Act, is available to individuals facing libel actions arising from publications in newspapers or periodicals. It constitutes a valid defense if the Defendant can demonstrate that the publication was made without malice and without gross negligence. To be effective, this defense must be accompanied by an apology published in the same newspaper or periodical where the libelous content appeared, either before the commencement of legal proceedings or at the earliest opportunity thereafter. Alternatively, if an apology has not been published, there must be an offer to publish such an apology.
2. Justification
A defendant must demonstrate that the allegations against the claimant are true in fact or substantially true. Pursuant to Section 14 of the Defamation Act, this defense remains applicable if the unproven statements do not significantly harm the claimant’s reputation in light of the truth of the other statements that have been proven.
3. Fair Comment
The defense of fair comment may be invoked when the impugned words consist partly of factual allegations and partly of opinion. For this defense to succeed, it must be demonstrated that:
- The subject matter of the comment pertains to a matter of legitimate public interest;
- The facts upon which the comment is based are true; and
- The comment is fair, in the sense that it is relevant to and based upon the proven facts.
4. Qualified Privilege
The essence of this defense is that the individual making the statement has a duty to communicate it, and the recipient has a corresponding interest in receiving it. The defense of qualified privilege applies to the following types of statements:
- Statements made in the discharge of a public or private duty;
- Statements made on subject matter in which the defendant has a legitimate interest;
- Statements made by the defendant to seek redress for a grievance;
- Reports of parliamentary proceedings; and
- Extracts from, or abstracts of, parliamentary reports, papers, votes, or proceedings published by the authority of Parliament.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the defenses against defamation in Kenya serve as crucial safeguards to balance the right to freedom of expression with the protection of individual reputations. By providing robust defenses such as truth, fair comment, and qualified privilege, the Defamation Act ensures that individuals can express their opinions and report on matters of public interest without fear of undue legal repercussions. These defenses emphasize the importance of truthfulness, public interest, and duty, thereby fostering a legal environment where free speech and accountability coexist. As defamation laws continue to evolve, these defenses will remain integral in upholding justice and protecting both the rights of individuals and the collective interests of society.
“The information provided in this article is intended for general legal advice and does not constitute legal advice for any specific transaction or case. Since each transaction presents a unique legal context, it is advisable to retain a legal adviser for specific transactions.”
To contact CR Advocates LLP, send us an email at info@cradvocatesllp.com or call +254 714887777 or Book a strategy call HERE or direct message us on WhatsApp at your convenience. Our legal team will be happy to help you.